Is it time for oxalic acid?

Synopsis: Efficient oxalic acid remedy calls for very little brood in colonies. Those stipulations will most likely happen in the following couple of weeks. How are you able to simply decide brood ranges within the wintry weather?

Advent

Many beekeepers will already be eager about the season forward. Making plans plans and scheming schemes. I be expecting that a lot of them (in all probability even you?) are making plans to increase their colony numbers.

Whether or not they accomplish that through merely splitting a colony and including a bought mated queen, or through rearing their very own queens and making up nucs, you most likely know that the probabilities of a a hit consequence are greater if the colony you get started with is powerful.

I’d outline good fortune merely as finishing up with extra robust colonies.

In the event you cut up a vulnerable colony there received’t be enough bees to thrive. They’ll combat to building up, they received’t gather a surplus of honey and they would get robbed out through wasps within the autumn.

Robust colonies clear up – or just steer clear of – nearly all of beekeeping issues. They’re higher ready to appear after themselves and a lot extra productive.

You’ll cut up a nuc off from a powerful colony, upload a virgin queen and simply finally end up with two very good colonies on the finish of the season.

What’s extra, the ‘parental’ colony will have to additionally produce a excellent crop of honey … and the fast-expanding nuc would possibly as smartly.

If the bees may just plan, they might additionally be intending to extend colony numbers subsequent season. Luck for a colony is measured each in survival from twelve months to the following and the manufacturing of swarms (replica).

Colonies that don’t swarm are inevitably doomed; hunger, fireplace, illness, failed queen mating or a marauding endure will – someday – lead to their dying.

The colony

The dimensions of the colony fluctuates all through the 12 months. You’ll measure it in various techniques – then again let’s simply center of attention on two of them for this put up:

• the overall collection of grownup bees, or
• the volume of brood (e.g. eggs, larvae or pupae) provide

Colony dimension, with regards to grownup employees (blue line, under), peaks someday in early summer season. Pupal quantity (inexperienced line) height a bit previous. At the moment of the season my hives (take into account that my bees are slightly darkish local or semi-natives) most definitely have 10-11 frames of brood and an grownup bee inhabitants of ~25,000.

Get used to this graph. It, or derivatives, will probably be showing once more.

In the event you run prolific Italian bees you’ll most definitely be considering that 10 or 11 frames of brood isn’t specifically robust …

Yadda yadda, no matter.

… whether or not your bees are vivid yellow or jet black, the colony dimension is smallest sooner or later within the wintry weather and biggest someday in early summer season.

The absolute numbers don’t subject.

Within the wintry weather the colony is composed of the long-lived (diutinus) wintry weather bees (and the queen in fact). Those employees have been reared overdue the former summer season and – assuming you minimised mite numbers and so lowered the degrees of the longevity-destroying deformed wing virus (DWV) – will nonetheless most commonly be provide the next early spring.

Spring building up

The colony must increase from the (somewhat small) wintry weather colony dimension to the (booming) early summer season inhabitants with a purpose to be robust sufficient to swarm.

This procedure is incessantly termed the ‘spring building up’ and comes to 3 interrelated components:

If the elements is awful the bees won’t be able to forage and building up will probably be retarded. Alternatively, even in excellent climate, if the surroundings lacks enough forage – spring nectars and pollen – building up will probably be behind schedule till it turns into to be had.

However integral to all the procedure is the supply of bees to rear new brood. Rearing a lot of brood calls for a lot of nurse bees.

It takes bees to make bees.

There’s no level within the queen laying up body after body of eggs if there are inadequate employees to stay the ensuing brood fed and heat.

So the wintry weather bees rear a small quantity of brood, which emerges and rears a little bit extra, which rears a little bit extra, and … you get the speculation.

Because the outdated wintry weather bees steadily die off they’re changed through new younger employees. Alternatively, for far of the primary month or two of the 12 months (and in all probability maximum of March and even into April) the general grownup bee inhabitants shrinks.

Some beekeepers time period the date when colonies begin to increase once more as crossover day – marked with an X at the graph above.

Gradual starters

Brood rearing begins slowly after which will increase; a couple of cells to begin with, then a couple of dozen, part a palm’s value on opposing frames, some lateral enlargement onto the adjoining frames and so forth.

If the bees get started rearing brood too early (blue dotted line above) they possibility operating out of wintry weather retail outlets; colony enlargement will stall if the elements is deficient they usually can not forage. If the retail outlets are exhausted, or foraging is not possible, the brood will probably be sacrificed or deserted. The colony would possibly starve in a chilly spring.

Alternatively, if they begin brood rearing too overdue (crimson dotted line above) the colony dimension won’t ever increase sufficiently in time to swarm. Probably the colony won’t even increase sufficient to have the forager numbers had to gather a honey surplus … survival over the next wintry weather is also in peril.

A steady get started is a organic inevitability. It additionally implies that somewhat few ‘assets’ (meals, effort, brood) are dedicated early within the season will have to stipulations go to pot.

Taking part in ‘catch up’

Why can’t they simply get started later and ‘catch up’ through rearing brood quicker?

As an example, if the beginning of the traditional spring building up (proven with the blue dotted line under) was once behind schedule, may just the colony simply rear extra brood quicker (proven with the crimson dotted line under)?

Most probably no longer. The charge of colony enlargement is proscribed through the collection of bees to be had to rear brood and – seriously – the 21 day building cycle of employees. This can’t be lowered … it’s invariant.

Actually, a charge restricting step.

So, sooner or later all through the wintry weather the bees wish to get started rearing the primary brood that can permit a well timed spring building up.

And the time they do that is in the following couple of weeks.

And ahead of that they’re going to be broodless.

Most likely.

By no means preventing

Relying upon your location, your bees might by no means be broodless within the wintry weather. Alternatively, there will be a duration within the wintry weather when brood ranges are low or very low.

The total form of the pupal inhabitants is equal to prior to now, it’s simply that the baseline is raised.

In the event that they rear brood right through the wintry weather the ‘space underneath the road’ will probably be greater. Hotter springs and autumns – a most likely prerequisite – will imply the hive is extra populous for an extended duration of the season. I couldn’t be to redraw the graph, so merely point out this with a few crimson arrows.

Alternatively, even if by no means broodless, there’ll nonetheless be a duration when brood ranges within the colony are minimum.

Why am I labouring this level?

The timing of the initiation of spring enlargement is significant for the explanations defined above. This enlargement follows a duration when the extent of brood is minimum or – in the event you’re lucky – 0.

‘Lucky’ since the much less sealed brood there may be within the colony, the larger the percentage of Varroa mites will probably be phoretic, piggybacking round at the our bodies of younger bees and – importantly – available to oxalic acid.

Oxalic acid (OA) is handiest efficient towards phoretic mites. It does no longer penetrate brood cappings and – after a unmarried management (which is what’s each advisable and authorized) – it handiest stays lively for a only a few days.

Subsequently, in the event you intend to regard with OA, it’s in point of fact vital to check out and determine the duration the place brood ranges within the colony are at an absolute minimal.

Preferably 0.

When is the colony broodless?

Sadly, you can’t simply expect when this ‘minimal brood’ duration happens.

Smartly, I will be able to’t, a minimum of no longer appropriately.

Its timing is influenced through a lot of issues, akin to:

• Age of the queen. Younger queens lay a lot later into the fall while outdated queens close up store somewhat early. Do additionally they get started previous?
• Ambient temperatures. If foraging is not possible because of the elements – rain or low temperatures – or futile as a result of there is not any forage then the colony is much less more likely to rear brood. If the temperature is so chilly the colony clusters then brood rearing is lowered.
• Photoperiod. It is a wager, however I wouldn’t be shocked if shorter overdue autumn days lowered brood rearing, even though setting apart the consequences of temperature or different environmental components may well be difficult.
• Colony energy? Natural hypothesis. How does colony energy affect the termination and restarting of brood rearing?

Autumn this 12 months (2023) has been surprisingly heat.

August was once lovely conventional over a lot of the rustic, however September and October – specifically in southern England – had imply temperatures 1.5° – 2.5°C hotter than a 30 12 months reasonable. I be expecting that this implies colonies can have reared brood later into the fall.

In earlier (less warm) years a few of my colonies were broodless in overdue October.

November is now reverting to kind. In my apiaries temperature maxima are actually 8-9°C and there are occasional frosts.

I’ve opened a number of colonies lately and they’re all roughly clustered. I’ve no longer seemed for brood … a minimum of indirectly. Alternatively, I’ve added trays beneath the open mesh flooring to search for proof of brood rearing not directly.

Pass with the proof …

If the colony is rearing brood there will probably be eggs, larvae and sealed pupae within the hive. It’s handiest in point of fact the sealed brood you want to be keen on with regards to ‘hidden’ mites.

To emerge from capped cells the totally evolved employees need to chunk during the biscuit-coloured pollen-impregnated wax cappings.

Those cappings fall during the cluster of bees, during the open mesh ground and onto the white Correx tray I’ve positioned beneath the ground.

They seem as a chain of fuzzy stripes, without delay beneath the parallel seams of bees.

The extra stripes there are, and the broader the ones stripes are, the extra brood is rising.

Go away the tray in position for 2-3 days after which take a look at it. If there may be proof of brood cappings at the tray take away it, blank it and put it again in per week or so.

While you take a look at a 2nd time come to a decision whether or not there are fewer and/or narrower stripes, or whether or not there are extra and wider.

If there are no ‘cappings’ stripes the colony is broodless. Lowering numbers or dimension of the stripes way it will have to quickly be broodless. If the stripes are strong or expanding the colony is constant to rear brood.

With two or 3 assessments right now of the 12 months you’ll be able to get an attractive excellent thought of what’s taking place within the hive.

To reach a well timed spring building up, many colonies will probably be rearing brood through overdue December. Right here in Scotland my colonies are virtually all broodless through early/mid-November (and from time to time previous), however they begin once more in December and feature capped brood through the top of the month.

… the precise proof

I described brood cappings as ‘biscuit-coloured pollen-impregnated wax’. Those crumbs are visual as fuzzy strains at the white Correx tray.

Don’t confuse those with the a lot paler colored cappings – that lack pollen – from uncapped retail outlets. Those are incessantly, even though no longer solely, from the outer edge of the brood nest.

Does this in point of fact subject?

Why cross to all this bother?

Why no longer do precisely what everybody else to your affiliation does and trickle deal with your colonies at the 30^th of December?

It’s a Saturday. You will have to would possibly have recovered from the excesses of Christmas and the recent air will revitalise you ahead of but extra overindulgence at Hogmanay.

Some associations even lend a hand their contributors deal with colonies within the lull between Christmas and New 12 months through distributing pre-made OA resolution, saving everybody the (negligible) bother of constructing their very own up.

Indisputably that might be more uncomplicated?

So, does it subject?

Sure … it does subject.

A minimum of it issues if you need your OA remedy to be maximally efficient. Why trouble doing it except this is your function?

I believe chemical remedy for mites a ‘essential evil’. I’d favor to not need to do it however, since I do deal with, I wish to slaughter as most of the little blighters as imaginable. That suggests 90-95% of them.

And to succeed in that I would like in an effort to get the oxalic acid to them.

90-95%

Oxalic acid may be very efficient – administered accurately – towards phoretic mites.

90-95% of phoretic mites are killed after OA publicity.

So what are the results of getting a little bit of sealed brood (by which a couple of mites are hiding) within the colony?

The extra mites which can be found in capped cells all through OA remedy, the larger the collection of mites that can live on to hurt the colony within the following season.

Let’s suppose there are a complete of 200 mites within the hive now.

Is that an unreasonable assumption?

Glance once more on the maps above; it’s been a very heat autumn.

Any mites surviving the summer season miticide remedy will most likely were busy reproducing within the brood reared overdue into the surprisingly heat autumn climate we’ve had.

So … 200 mites. OK?

Right here’s a graph appearing the collection of mites that live on OA remedy (the black bars) relying upon the proportion of the ones mites which can be hiding in capped cells on the time of remedy. I’ve assumed an efficacy of 95% for OA remedy in those calculations.

If there is not any sealed brood within the hive (all the mites are phoretic) then handiest 10 of the 200 mites will live on the remedy.

That’s an excellent begin to the season forward.

Alternatively, if 50% of the mites are in capped cells, 105 of the 200 will live on remedy.

Hmmm … no longer so excellent.

In the end, if there’s a large number of sealed brood and 90% of the mites are in capped cells (see under) then 181 of the 200 will live on.

You too can no longer trouble treating. The disturbance to the colony when dousing them in OA will most definitely do extra harm to the bees than to the mites.

Long term issues

The extra mites provide in the beginning of the 12 months, the earlier the inhabitants of reproducing mites will exceed 1000. That is the quantity the Nationwide Bee Unit considers is the extent at which remedy will have to be carried out.

With 181 initially of the 12 months, mite ranges will exceed 1000 through mid-Might. Lowering mite numbers to 105 will get you to the start of June. Killing enough phoretic mites for handiest 67 to live on buys you any other fortnight or so. If handiest 29 mites are provide initially of the 12 months then the 1000 threshold isn’t exceeded till the start of July.

Alternatively, in the event you handiest have 10 mites provide in the beginning of January the edge isn’t exceeded till October … in which time you’ll have already carried out the fall remedy.

Those calculations have been performed with Randy’s Varroa style on the internet (a browser-based model of Randy Oliver’s Varroa style) run on the default settings excluding I exploit the ‘exhausting wintry weather style’ which higher displays the United Kingdom local weather.

What number of mites are in capped cells within the wintry weather?

I don’t know.

In the summertime the determine is normally quoted as ~90% however I’m no longer acutely aware of any research that experience correctly measured this within the wintry weather.

With restricting quantities of brood it’s most likely that mites will take longer to discover a cellular containing a suitably elderly larvae to infest. There is also lowered mobility of bees throughout the cluster, additional decreasing mite get right of entry to to larvae.

I might be expecting that the proportion of mites in capped cells – all different issues being equivalent – can be (widely) without delay proportional to the volume of brood within the wintry weather colony.

The extra brood, the fewer phoretic mites … any other compelling explanation why to regard when the colony is as with reference to broodless as imaginable.

Something I’m positive of … if there’s no sealed brood then all the mites will probably be phoretic.

Trickle or vape?

Trickle.

Oh, you need to understand why?

For many beekeepers I believe trickle treating with oxalic acid is essentially the most good possibility. I believe it makes specific sense while you handiest have a couple of hives to regard.

In the beginning it way you don’t wish to acquire an OA vaporiser (£30 to £300+), an influence provide and the the related PPE wanted to make use of it safely.

Secondly, trickle treating is quicker. Don’t consider the vapaholics who declare 30 seconds in step with hive. This determine assumes a pricey ‘lively’ vaporiser (like a Sublimox) and ignores sealing the hive correctly … and ready enough time (~5 mins, till all the vapour has settled) ahead of unsealing it afterwards.

I’ve a Sublimox and I’ve performed timed comparisons of vaping and trickling and the latter is quicker (Sure, I in point of fact wish to get out extra).

In the end, the authorized, commercially to be had OA powder (Api-Bioxal) comprises glucose which caramelises and makes an unholy mess of a vaporiser.

There are two stipulations when OA vaporisation might be preferable to trickle treating:

1. You probably have many adjoining hives (10+) to regard and you’ll be able to seal/unseal them abruptly. An assistant is helping.
2. If there’s open brood within the hive. The acidity of OA damages (i.e. kills) larvae and research from LASI in Sussex (Al Toufailia et al., 2015) confirmed that trickle handled colonies with open brood have been weaker in spring.

And, ahead of any person asks … I’ve coated repeated OA remedy prior to now. It’s no longer allowed in the United Kingdom and I’ve but to look any compelling proof that it’s as efficient as trickle treating a broodless colony within the wintry weather.

I don’t make the principles … however I additionally handiest advertise strategies I do know are efficient.

---

Notes

The graphs of pupal and grownup bee numbers have been modelled the use of BEEHAVE (Becher et al., 2014) run with the default settings for latitude and climate (Rothamstead).

References

Al Toufailia, H., Scandian, L., and Ratnieks, F.L.W. (2015) Against built-in keep watch over of varroa: 2)evaluating software strategies and doses of oxalic acid at the mortality of phoretic Varroa destructor mites and their honey bee hosts. Magazine of Apicultural Analysis 54: 108–120 https://doi.org/10.1080/00218839.2015.1106777.

Becher, M.A., Grimm, V., Thorbek, P., Horn, J., Kennedy, P.J., and Osborne, J.L. (2014) BEEHAVE: a programs style of honeybee colony dynamics and foraging to discover multifactorial reasons of colony failure. Magazine of Implemented Ecology 51: 470–482 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1365-2664.12222.